I called McAfee Support and they helped me with this action.
So how did you do to resolve problems
The Tech from McAfee was going so fast I didn't see all the steps he performed. I would try to recreate the Automatic Response, the tech deleted my original and set it up this way (screenshot). I have not had any problems since he made the changes. If this does not work, i would recommend call them, they have excellent phone support.
Make sure you choose the right values and you will manually have to type in the part after the colon.
Hope this helps